Howie Mandel’s reaction to 13-year-old Evelyn Errante’s powerhouse audition on “Defying Gravity” had angry fans booing the AGT judge and calling him “disrespectful”

 

13-year-old Evelyn Errante was a major fan favorite at America’s Got Talent 2025, but the judges’ reaction to her audition left fans fuming! The teen, who Sofia Vergara said had some major princess vibes, brought the house down with her sensational rendition of “Defying Gravity” from Wicked. Evelyn showcased a bubbly personality in the opening interview of her July 30 audition, instantly charming the audience. She then bowled them over with her confidence as a performer and her powerhouse vocals.

Despite her young age, Evelyn is a complete vocalist, and showed her mastery of every technique in the book. She also nailed the emotional delivery of Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth’s hit. She’s definitely got the kind of voice that can run shivers down your spine. The Music Man readers won’t be surprised to hear that the audience was all on their feet and cheering by the end. The judges were more muted though, remaining seated, and their comments would cause some major controversy among viewers.

Judge Howie Mandel was not impressed by Evelyn’s audition, voting no and saying, “What you want to do is not really something I respond to.” He was roundly booed by the audience for this take. Mel B gave a somewhat lukewarm response, saying, “The good thing is, you can sing like that at 13. By the time you get to 18, your voice is going to be amazing. Keep on going, keep on training.”

Fans in the comments could not understand this underwhelming reception, adding comments such as “Are these judges nuts?? I hate musicals but this sent chills through my body. Amazing talent. They have no objective viewpoint” and “Howie is being disrespectful here. It’s valid to dislike a certain genre of music, but as a judge himself he should still have the ability to acknowledge how talented she is.” Another memorable performance of “Defying Gravity” came when Idina Menzel sang it at Barefoot at the Symphony.

Sofia Vergara was the only judge to give all-around positive feedback, saying, “It was amazing. I think you’re going to go very, very far.” Vergara then voted yes, and Mel B likewise gave Evelyn a yes vote, despite giving her mixed feedback.
At the end of the segment, it came down to Simon Cowell’s call. Cowell didn’t seem convinced at first, saying, “I cannot bear that song.” He did come around, however, saying, “You’ve got so much ambition. We should encourage someone like you on this show.” The Music Man is pleased to report that Cowell gave Evelyn’s audition a happy ending, giving her his vote and sending her home with three yes votes.

Article Sources & Discover More