How many musicians can say they had two of the greatest songwriters of all time pay tribute to them with a duet? The one and only Carole King had that honor when Billy Joel and James Taylor played her hit “Crying in the Rain,” as Carole watched in the front row. Seeing Carole’s look of joy after the duet said it all. Needless to say, as one fan put it, “The Piano Man and The Handy Man” sound absolutely legendary as a vocal duo.
Carole wrote “Crying in the Rain” for The Everly Brothers, who are one of the great vocal duos. The combination of James and Billy’s voices did justice to their work and was elegantly complemented by James’ acoustic guitar and Billy’s piano. James took the lead vocal for most of the song, with his reedier tone blending perfectly with Billy’s sonorous voice. The Music Man has to say that seeing how happy James and Billy were to sing together made the performance really heartwarming.
Billy and James performed together at the Library of Congress’s Gershwin Prize for Popular Song, of which Carole was the recipient that year. Viewers added comments such as “What a great rendition for these two icons of the music industry. Proud to be in the same generation as such great musicians and songwriters as them” and “The two big ones! Glad to watch them play together. James is still able to turn any song into one of his.”
The Everly Brothers gave a number of cracking performances of “Crying in the Rain”. One of their most memorable was their duet on the song on The Ed Sullivan Show in February 1962, just two months after the release of the song. The brothers were active duty Marines at the time of the performance and appeared on the show in their uniforms, having recently graduated from boot camp.
Carole King wrote the music for “Crying in the Rain” and Howard Greenfield penned the lyrics. The Music Man readers may recall that The Everly Brothers were the first to record the song, and they released their version on December 22, 1961. The Everly Brothers’ single hit number six on the US Billboard Hot 100. “Crying in the Rain” has since been covered by many artists. Tammy Wynette scored a US Hot Country Songs top 20 hit with the song in 1982. In 1990, A-ha released the most popular version of the ballad since the original, with the Norwegian band’s version hitting the top 10 in a number of European markets.